|
Overview of Case Study of UPS
Business process reengineering efforts suffer from low success rates, due
in part to a lack of tools for managing the change process. The Matrix
of Change can help managers identify critical interactions among processes.
In particular, this tool helps managers deal with issues such as how quickly
change should proceed, the order in which changes should take place, whether
to start at a new site, and whether the proposed systems are stable and
coherent.
The goal of the Matrix of Change is to help managers visualize how to
address changes in business processes and system changes. Change invariably
disrupts existing business processes, and business process and system
changes must be aligned and managed effectively to achieve intended performance
gains. The Matrix of Change captures the key elements of a proposed change
and presents in a framework which makes it easier to investigate the complementary
and conflicting processes. The Matrix of Change presents a way to capture
connections between practices. It graphically displays both reinforcing
and interfering organizational processes.
Armed with this knowledge, a change agent can use intuitive principles
to seek points of leverage and design a smoother transition. Once the
broad outlines of the new system and the transition path have been charted,
authority can more effectively be decentralized for local implementation
and optimization. . We devote more specific attention to the transformational
efforts successfully navigated at United Parcel Service (UPS) in its competitive
responses to Federal Express and the dramatic changes in Internet-enabled,
package and document delivery services worldwide. Throughout our focus
on complementarities leads us to ask how companies can capture both the
new opportunities made available by the Internet, and the leveraging of
existing assets to grow new markets at rates applicable to the economic
needs of the large firm. While small firms can often most quickly respond
to the opportunities for growth in emerging markets, it is the large firm
that can grow these markets by leveraging their assets to bring scale-based
economies to the market. But this is much easier said than done of course.
Within large firms, it is often the resource allocation processes, both
formal and informal, which make it difficult to focus adequate expertise
and resources on small markets. We have observed that the Matrix of Change
can help managers visualize and identify what resources should be deployed
where and when, and where these resources complement or conflict with
existing business practices.
|
TOC |